COPYRIGHT 2017 DUN & BRADSTREET INC. - PROVIDED UNDER CONTRACT
                FOR THE EXCLUSIVE USE OF SUBSCRIBER 100-150009.

                     ATTN: Request Submitted by DnB Exp

                             COMPREHENSIVE REPORT

DUNS: 80-473-5132
GORMAN MANUFACTURING COMPANY,
INC.                                    FINANCIAL STRESS CLASS: 4
                                        CREDIT SCORE CLASS:     5
492 KOLLER ST                           D&B VIABILITY RATING:  27AA
AND BRANCH(ES) OR DIVISION(S)                      KEY
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110                 =============================
TEL: 650 555-0000                      LOWEST RISK      HIGHEST RISK
                                           1    2    3    4    5
SIC:      27 52
LINE OF BUSINESS: LITHOGRAPHIC COMMERCIAL PRINTING
YEAR STARTED:      1985
CONTROL DATE:      1985                         DATE PRINTED: SEP 12 2017

CHIEF EXECUTIVE: LESLIE SMITH, PRES

===============================================================================
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

- The Financial Stress Class of 4 for this company shows that during the
  previous year, firms with this classification had a failure rate of
  .84% (84 per 10,000), which is 1.75 times higher than the national average.
- The Credit Score Class of 5 for this company shows that during the previous
  year, 53.1% of the firms with this classification paid one or more bills
  severely delinquent, which is 5.21 times higher than the national average.
- Subject company pays its bills an average 42 days beyond terms.
- Subject company's industry pays its bills an average 9 days beyond terms.
- Subject company pays its bills slower than the average for its industry.
- Financial information from a fiscal consolidated statement dated 12/31/16
  is included.
- Sales for the fiscal year ending December 2016 are up by 23.7%.
- Net worth for the fiscal year ending December 2016 is down by 12.5%.
- Operations are profitable.
- UCC filing(s) are reported for this business.
- Financing is secured.
- Under present management control 32 years.
- Evidence of open Suit(s), Lien(s) and Judgment(s) in the D&B database.
- History is clear.

===============================================================================
VIABILITY RATING

The D&B viability rating uses D&B's proprietary analytics to compare the most
predictive business risk indicators and deliver a highly reliable assessment
of the probability that a company will no longer be in business within the next
12 months.

D&B VIABILITY RATING:  27AA

D&B VIABILITY COMPONENTS

VIABILITY SCORE

Viability Score is the first of four components within the D&B Viability
Rating. It is a high-level risk indicator that assesses the probability that a
company will no longer be in business within the next 12 months, compared to
all US businesses within the D&B database. A business is no longer viable when
it goes out of business, becomes dormant/inactive or files for bankruptcy.
The ranking ranges from 1 to 9 where 9 reflects the highest probability of
becoming no longer viable and 1 reflects the lowest probability.

NOTE: The Viability Score is best used when ranking all businesses within your
portfolio based on the probability of becoming no longer viable.

RATING: 2        LOW RISK                  HIGH RISK

                 <1--<2>--3---4---5---6---7---8---9>

Compared to All US Businesses within D&B Database:

Level of risk: Low Risk
Businesses ranked 2 have a probability of becoming no longer viable: 2%
Percentage of businesses ranked 2: 4%
Across all US businesses, the average probability of becoming no longer
viable: 14%

PORTFOLIO COMPARISON

Portfolio Comparison is the second of four components within the D&B Viability
Rating. Portfolio Comparison is a more detailed risk indicator that assesses
the viability of a company compared to similar businesses within the same model
segment which are determined by the amount and type of data available.
A business is no longer viable when it goes out of business, becomes dormant/
inactive or files for bankruptcy. Every business within the D&B database falls
into 1 of the following 4 profile segments:

        Available Financial Data
        Established Trade Payments
        Limited Trade Payments
        Firmographics and Business Activity

The Portfolio Comparison ranking ranges from 1 to 9 where 9 reflects the
highest probability of becoming no longer viable and 1 reflects the lowest
probability.

NOTE: The Portfolio Comparison is best used when analyzing the individual risk
level of a company compared to businesses within the same profile segment.

RATING: 7        LOW RISK                  HIGH RISK

                 <1---2---3---4---5---6--<7>--8---9>

Compared to all Businesses within the same MODEL SEGMENT:

Model Segment: Available Financial Data

Level of risk: High to Moderate Risk
Businesses ranked 7 within this model segment have a probability of
becoming no longer viable: 1%
Percentage of businesses ranked 7 within this model segment: 10%
Within this model segment, the average probability of becoming no
longer viable: 0.6%

DATA DEPTH INDICATOR

Data Depth Indicator is the third of four components within the D&B Viability
Rating. The Depth of data Indicator presents the level of data available for a
company. Data depth assists in the assessment of whether a company will no
longer be viable and includes the following:

        Financial Attributes
        Commercial Trading Activity
        Firmographics

The level of data is represented by a letter on a scale of A - G where A
reflects the greatest level of predictive data to make a highly reliable
assessment of company viability, and G reflects a minimal level of data which
can be considered descriptive. The more comprehensive the data, the more
precise the overall D&B Viability Rating becomes. If a company has been placed
in the Special Category, a letter ranging from H-M will be assigned to
identify the specific reason.

DATA DEPTH A

Data Depth Indicator Details:

Rich Firmographics
Extensive Commercial Trading Activity
Comprehensive Financial Attributes

COMPANY PROFILE

Company Profile is the fourth of four components within the D&B Viability
Rating. The Company profile describes a company based on a combination of 4
categories:

        Financial Data
        Trade Payments
        Company Size
        Years in Business

A company is characterized by a letter which ranges from A - X; with each
letter representing a combination of the 4 categories that make up the
company's profile. For example, A describes a company with a comprehensive
level data, which has been in business 5+ years, with 50+ employees or $500k+
in Sales, while X reflects a company with a minimal data, in business <5 years,
with <10 employees and <$10k in Sales. Y and Z reflect a Branch and Subsidiary
respectively.

COMPANY PROFILE A

Company Profile Details:

Financial Data    : Available
Trade Payments    : Available: 3+Trade
Business Size     : Large: Employees:50+ or Sales: $500K+
Years in Business : Established: 5+
===============================================================================
CREDIT CAPACITY SUMMARY

D&B Rating:     3A4                Payment Activity
                                     (based on 16 experiences):
Sales ($):      24,662,580            Average High Credit:    $95,937
# of Employees                        Highest Credit:         $1,000,000
Total:          153                   Total Highest Credits:  $1,535,000
               (120 Here)

As of 12/31/16  Worth:            $1,365,009
                Working Capital:  $2,286,332

Note: The Worth amount in this section may have been adjusted by D&B to reflect
typical deductions, such as certain intangible assets.

===============================================================================
FINANCIAL STRESS SUMMARY

The Financial Stress Model predicts the likelihood of business failure  which
includes ceasing business without paying all creditors in full, reorganization
or obtaining relief from creditors under state/federal law over the next 12
months. Scores were calculated using a statistically valid model derived from
D&B's extensive data files.


 Financial Stress Class:                               4
 (Highest Risk: 5; Lowest Risk: 1)

 Probability of Failure Among
 Businesses with this Class:                           0.84% (84 per 10,000)

 Financial Stress National Percentile:                 9
 (Highest Risk: 1; Lowest Risk: 100)

 Financial Stress Score:                            1397
 (Highest Risk: 1,001; Lowest Risk: 1,875)

 Probability of Failure :                              0.48% (48 per 10,000)
 - Average of businesses in D&B's database

The Financial Stress Score of this business is based on the following factors:

   - Composite credit appraisal is rated limited.
   - Financial ratios indicate higher risk.
   - High proportion of slow payment experiences to total number of payment
     experiences.
   - Low proportion of satisfactory payment experiences to total payment
     experiences.
   - UCC Filings reported.
   - Unstable Paydex over last 12 months.

 Notes:

- The Financial Stress Class indicates that this firm shares some of
the same business and financial characteristics of other companies with
this classification.  It does not mean the firm will necessarily
experience financial stress.

- The Probability of failure shows percentage of firms in a
given percentile that discontinue operations with loss to creditors.
The average probability of failure is based on businesses in
D&B's database and is provided for comparative purposes.

- The Financial Stress National Percentile reflects the relative
ranking of a company among all scorable companies in D&B's file.

- The Financial Stress Score offers a more precise measure of the level
of risk than the Class and Percentile.  It is especially helpful to
customers using a scorecard approach to determining overall business
performance.

===============================================================================
FINANCIAL STRESS NORMS
                                                                      National
Norms for Companies in the Same ...                                  Percentile

     - Region  (PACIFIC)                                                 52

     - Industry: MANUFACTURING                                           52

     - Employee Range (100-499)                                          75

     - Years in Business Range (26+)                                     77

     - Subject Company                                                    9

Key Comparisons
The subject company has a Financial Stress Percentile that shows:

   - Higher risk than other companies in the same region.
   - Higher risk than other companies in the same industry.
   - Higher risk than other companies in the same employee size range.
   - Higher risk than other companies with a comparable number of years in
     business.

===============================================================================
CREDIT SCORE SUMMARY

The Commercial Credit Score predicts the likelihood that a company will pay its
bills in a severely delinquent manner (91 days or more past terms), obtain
legal relief from creditors or cease operations without paying all creditors in
full over the next 12 months.  Scores are calculated using a statistically
valid model derived from D&B's extensive data files.

Credit Score Class:                              5

Incidence of Delinquent Payment Among
Companies with this Class:                      53.10%

Percentile:                                      5

Credit Score:                                  302

Incidence of Delinquent Payment:                10.20%
- Average compared to businesses in D&B's database

The Credit Score of this business is based on the following factors:

  - Evidence of negative trade
  - Recent amount past due
  - Proportion of slow payment experiences to total number of payment
    experiences reported
  - Vendor payment commentary
  - Payment information indicates negative payment comments

Notes:

  - The Commercial Credit Score Risk Class indicates that this firm shares
    some of the same business and financial characteristics of other
    companies with this classification. It does not mean the firm will
    necessarily experience severe delinquency.

  - The Incidence of Delinquent Payment is the percentage of companies with
    this classification that were reported 91 days past due or more by
    creditors. The calculation of this value is based on D&B's trade
    payment database.

  - The Commercial Credit Score percentile reflects the relative ranking of
    a firm among all scorable companies in D&B's file.

  - The Commercial Credit Score offers a more precise measure of the level
    of risk than the Risk Class and Percentile. It is especially helpful to
    customers using a scorecard approach to determining overall business
    performance.


===============================================================================
CREDIT SCORE NORMS
                                                                      National
Norms for Companies in the Same ...                                  Percentile

     - Region  (PACIFIC)                                                 50

     - Industry: MANUFACTURING                                           62

     - Employee Range (100-499)                                          89

     - Years in Business Range (26+)                                     85

     - Subject Company                                                    5

Key Comparisons
The subject company has a Credit Score Percentile that shows:

   - Higher risk than other companies in the same region.
   - Higher risk than other companies in the same industry.
   - Higher risk than other companies in the same employee size range.
   - Higher risk than other companies with a comparable number of years in
     business.



===============================================================================
PAYMENT TRENDS

PAYDEX scores below are based on dollar weighted trade in most recent 12 mos.

                '15 '16 '16 '16 '16 '16 '16 '17 '17 '17 '17 '17 '17 '17 '17 '17
                DEC MAR JUN SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP

FIRM             79  75  76  78  76  76  75  75  75  75  68  55  55  43  46  46

Industry
Quartiles
----------
Upper            79  79  79  79          79          79          79
Median           74  74  74  74          72          74          74
Lower            66  66  65  65          65          65          65

   Industry PAYDEX based on:       KEY TO PAYDEX SCORES:
   SIC:  2752                        79   2 Days Beyond Terms
   169 Firms                         74   9 Days Beyond Terms
                                     43  51 Days Beyond Terms

===============================================================================
SUMMARY OF PAYMENT HABITS

Dollar Range Comparisons:

Suppliers That          Number of        Total       % of Dollars
Extend Credit of...     Experiences:     Amount      Within Terms

                             #             $              %

OVER $100,000                2        1,100,000           5
$50,000 - 99,999             3          230,000          50
$15,000 - 49,999             6          165,000          42
$ 5,000 - 14,999             5           40,000          34
$ 1,000 - 4,999              0                0           0
    Under 1,000              0                0           0

===============================================================================
PAYMENT ANALYSIS BY INDUSTRY

There are 16 payment experiences in D&B's file for the most recent 12 months,
with 15 experiences reported during the last three month period.

                      Total     Dollar    Highest   Within Slow Slow  Slow Slow
                      Recd      Amount    Credit    Terms  1-30 31-60 61-90 91+
                       #           $         $       --- % of dollar amount ---

Total in D&B's File    16      1,535,000  1,000,000

Industry

Car body repair/paint   5      1,205,000  1,000,000     9  41     4   46    0
Ret misc vehicles       5        172,500     95,000    47   7     5   41    0
Real estate agent/mgr   5        132,500     50,000    49  19     8   24    0
Whol plumb/hydronics    1         25,000     25,000     0   0   100    0    0

OTHER PAYMENT CATEGORIES:
Cash Experiences        0              0
Paying Record Unknown   0              0
Unfavorable Comments    0              0
Placed for Collection
  with D&B              0              0
  other                 0            N/A

Indications of slowness can be the result of disputes over merchandise, skipped
invoices, etc.

===============================================================================
PUBLIC FILINGS SUMMARY

The following data includes both open and closed filings found in
D&B's database on the subject company.

                                                       Most Recent
            Record Type                    #           Filing Date

     Bankruptcy Proceedings                0                -
     Judgments                             3            01/01/2014
     Liens                                 1            01/01/2014
     Suits                                 1            02/01/2014
     UCC's                                 2            01/01/2014

===============================================================================
PUBLIC FILINGS DETAIL

         The following data is for information purposes only and is not the
         official record.  Certified copies can only be obtained from the
         official source.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                           * * * JUDGMENT(S) * * *
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILING NO.: 123456
JDGMT AWARD: $700                             STATUS: Unsatisfied
JDGMT TYPE:  Judgment                         DATE STATUS ATTAINED:  01/01/2014
AGAINST:     GORMAN MANUFACTURING COMPANY     DATE ENTERED:          01/01/2014
             INC - TEST CASE                  LATEST INFO RECEIVED:  04/07/2014
IN FAVOR OF: ABC MANUFACTURING - TEST CASE
WHERE FILED: Los Angeles, County Of, Norwalk
             CA
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCKET NO.: nmjtest05
JDGMT AWARD: Other                            STATUS: Unsatisfied
JDGMT TYPE:  Judgment                         DATE STATUS ATTAINED:  01/01/2008
AGAINST:     Gorman Mfg (Test Case)           DATE ENTERED:          01/01/2008
IN FAVOR OF: Test Plaintiff                   LATEST INFO COLLECTED: 01/01/2008
WHERE FILED: RECORDER OF DEEDS, NORWALK, CA
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOCKET NO.: nmjtest01
JDGMT TYPE:  Judgment                         STATUS: Unsatisfied
AGAINST:     Gorman Mfg Test                  DATE STATUS ATTAINED:  01/01/2008
IN FAVOR OF: Test Plaintiff                   DATE ENTERED:          01/01/2008
WHERE FILED: RECORDER OF DEEDS, NORWALK, CA   LATEST INFO COLLECTED: 01/02/2008
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                             * * * SUIT(S) * * *
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILING NO.: 99999
SUIT AMOUNT: $750                             STATUS: Pending
PLAINTIFF:   TEST CASE                        DATE STATUS ATTAINED:  02/01/2014
DEFENDANT:   GORMAN MANUFACTURING INC - TEST  DATE FILED:            02/01/2014
             CASE                             LATEST INFO RECEIVED:  04/07/2014
WHERE FILED: Supreme Court Of The State Of
             Tennessee, Knoxville, TN
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                             * * * LIEN(S) * * *
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILING NO.: 14011411111
AMOUNT:   $500                                STATUS: Open
TYPE:     State Tax                           DATE STATUS ATTAINED:  01/01/2014
FILED BY: BOARD OF EQUALIZATION - TEST CASE,  DATE FILED:            01/01/2014
          SAN FRANCISCO, CA                   LATEST INFO RECEIVED:  04/07/2014
AGAINST:  GORMAN MANUFACTURING COMPANY INC -
          TEST CASE
WHERE FILED: California Secretary Of State,
             Sacramento, CA
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                           * * * UCC FILING(S) * * *
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILING NO:  77777                             DATE FILED:            01/01/2014
TYPE:       Original                          LATEST INFO RECEIVED:  05/02/2014
SEC. PARTY: VAL MAGEE - TEST, ALLENTOWN, PA   FILED WITH: SECRETARY OF
DEBTOR:     GORMAN MANUFACTURING COMPANY INC              STATE/UCC DIVISION,
            - TEST CASE                                   LEHIGH, PA
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILING NO:  55555                             DATE FILED:            01/01/2014
TYPE:       Original                          LATEST INFO RECEIVED:  01/03/2014
SEC. PARTY: TEST CASE BUSINESS 1, DUBLIN,     FILED WITH: SECRETARY OF
            IRELAND                                       STATE/UCC DIVISION,
DEBTOR:     GORMAN MANUFACTURING COMPANY                  PA
            and OTHERS
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

         The public record items contained in this report may have been
         paid, terminated, vacated or released prior to the date this
         report was printed.

===============================================================================
BUSINESS BACKGROUND

                                     HISTORY
         ----------------------------------------------------------------------
         CORPORATE AND BUSINESS REGISTRATIONS REPORTED BY THE SECRETARY
         OF STATE OR OTHER OFFICIAL SOURCE AS OF 09/01/2017:

         This data is for informational purposes only, certification can only
         be obtained through the Sacramento Office of the Californiaa Secretary
         of State.

         BUSINESS TYPE: CORPORATION -       DATE INCORPORATED: 01/03/1977
                        PROFIT              STATE OF INCORP:   CALIFORNIA
         ----------------------------------------------------------------------
03/06/17
         LESLIE SMITH, PRES                 KEVIN J HUNT, SEC-TREAS
         DIRECTOR(S):  THE OFFICER(S)

              The California  Secretary of State's business registrations file
         showed that Gorman Manufacturing Company, Inc. was registered as a
         Corporation on May 21, 1985.
              Business started 1985 by Leslie Smith and Kevin J Hunt.  60% of
         capital stock is owned by Leslie Smith.  40% of capital stock is owned
         by Kevin J Hunt.
              LESLIE SMITH born 1946.  Graduated from the University of
         California, Los Angeles, CA, in June 1967 with a BS degree in Business
         Management.  1967-85 General Manager for Raymor Printing Co, San
         Francisco, CA.  1985 formed subject with Kevin J Hunt.  1985 to
         present active as Principal in Gorman Affiliate Ltd, San Francisco,
         CA.
              KEVIN J HUNT born 1945.  Graduated from Northwestern University,
         Evanston, IL in June 1966.  1966-1985 was General Manager for Raymor
         Printing Co, San Francisco, CA.  1985 formed subject with Leslie
         Smith.  1985 to present active as Principal in Gorman Affiliate Ltd,
         San Francisco, CA.
              AFFILIATE: The following is related through common principals,
         management and/or ownership.  Gorman Affiliate Ltd, San Francisco, CA,
         started 1985.  Operates as commercial printer.  Intercompany
         relations: None reported by management.

                                    OPERATIONS

03/06/17      Engaged in commercial lithographic printing (100%).
         Terms are Net 30 days. Has 240 account(s).  Sells to commercial
         concerns.  Territory : United States.
         Nonseasonal.
              EMPLOYEES:  153 which includes officer(s).  120 employed here.
              FACILITIES:  Occupies premises in a one story cinder block
         building.
              LOCATION:  Central business section on well traveled street.
              BRANCHES:  This business has multiple branches, detailed
         branch/division information is available in D&B's linkage of family
         tree products.
              SUBSIDIARIES:  This business has multiple subsidiaries, detailed
         subsidiary information is available in D&Bs linkage or family tree
         products.

                             OTHER CORPORATE DETAILS
CORPORATE STATUS:  SUSPENDED
CORPORATE AGENT:   DENNIS L GORMAN, 1324 E BEAMER, WOODLAND, CA
STATE ID NO:       C0806110


===============================================================================
FINANCIAL SUMMARY

                           KEY BUSINESS RATIOS

             Based on a Financial Statement Dated December 31, 2016

                  (Industry Norms Based on 46 Establishments)

          Profitability       Short-Term        Efficiency         Utilization
                %             Solvency             (%)                 (%)
          Return   Return    Curr   Quick    Assets/  Sales/      Total Liabs/
         on Sales  on Net    Ratio  Ratio     Sales  Net working    Net Worth
                   Worth                               Capital

Firm        0.8      9.2      1.3    1.1      50.2       10.8        499.7

Industry    2.8     10.4      2.3    1.8      51.0        7.7         75.3
Median

Industry    4        3        3      3         2          2            4
Quartile

                             FINANCIAL INFORMATION

03/06/17                           Fiscal            Fiscal            Fiscal
                             Consolidated      Consolidated      Consolidated
                              Dec 31 2014       Dec 31 2015       Dec 31 2016
         Curr Assets           10,084,060         9,624,779        11,284,644
         Curr Liabs             8,157,897         6,928,698         8,998,312
         Current Ratio               1.24              1.39              1.25
         Working Capital        1,926,163         2,696,081         2,286,332
         Other Assets           1,625,409         1,341,572         1,101,197
         Worth                  1,490,077         1,559,877         2,065,239
         Sales                 20,839,372        19,945,238        24,662,580
         Long Term Liab         2,061,495         2,477,776         1,322,290
         Net Profit (Loss)        157,228           179,974           189,127
              Fiscal Consolidated statement dated DEC 31 2016:
         Cash               $       532,763  Accts Pay          $     6,275,432
         Accts Rec                8,927,402  Accruals                     5,656
         Inventory                1,573,335  L.T. Liab-(1yr)          2,656,435
         Other Curr Assets          251,144  Other Curr Liabs            60,789
                            ---------------                     ---------------
           Curr Assets           11,284,644    Curr Liabs             8,998,312
         Fixt & Equip             1,025,657  L.T. Liab-Other          1,322,290
         Deposits                     5,635  COMMON STOCK                50,000
         Other Assets                69,905  ADDIT. PD.-IN CAP          650,230
                                             NET WORTH                1,365,009
                            ---------------                     ---------------
           Total Assets          12,385,841    Total                 12,385,841
              From JAN 01 2016 to DEC 31 2016 annual sales
         $24,662,580; cost of goods sold $19,965,222.  Gross profit
         $4,697,358; operating expenses $3,695,832.  Operating income
         $1,001,526; other expenses $641,590; net income before taxes
         $359,936; Federal income tax $170,809.  Net income $189,127.
              Statement received by mail APR 01 2016.  Prepared from
         statement(s) by Accountant: Johnson, Jordan & Jones CPAs.
              ACCOUNTANTS OPINION:  A review of the accountant's opinion
         indicates the financial statements meet generally accepted accounting
         principles and that the audit contains no qualifications.
                                        --0--
              Fixed assets shown net less $92,569 depreciation.
              On March 6, 2017, the financial information was updated for
         subject company.


===============================================================================
                                 CUSTOMER SERVICE
If you need any additional information, or have any questions regarding this
report, please call our Customer Service Center at (800) 234-3867 from
anywhere within the U.S.  From outside the U.S., please call your local D&B
office.

                            END OF COMPREHENSIVE REPORT
CLAUSE DE NON-RESPONSABILITÉ : CE RAPPORT NE PEUT ÊTRE REPRODUIT EN TOUT OU EN PARTIE DE QUELQUE MANIÈRE QUE CE SOIT. Le présent rapport, fourni sur une base contractuelle, est destiné à l'usage exclusif du souscripteur en tant que facteur de considération relativement aux décisions de crédit, de marketing ou autres décisions commerciales, et contient de l'information compilée à partir de sources que D&B Canada ne peut contrôler, et qui, à moins d'indication contraire au rapport, n'a pas été vérifiée. D&B Canada ne sera aucunement tenue responsable du risque commercial encouru par l'utilisateur, et ne garantit pas l'exactitude, l'intégralité ou l'opportunité de l'information fournie, et ne sera pas tenue responsable de pertes ou dommages, quels qu'ils soient, résultant de circonstances imprévues au-delà de son contrôle ou de négligence.